All right, after a thorough amount of listening, I'm finally done, haha.
First of all, thank you so much for all of the recommendations, I really appreciate any recommendations at all and you gave me so much more than I expected.
From my listenings, I really like Keith Urban, Tim McGraw, Carrie Underwood, Sugarland, and Brad Paisley. I actually went out on Wednesday and got Keith Urban's Golden Road album, and...I got Tim McGraw's Greatest Hits album, but I got it used and someone put the disc for his And the Dancehall Doctors album in there instead, lol. I'm enjoying the album anyway, though, so I'm only slightly annoyed at having the wrong case. Thoroughly enjoying Golden Road, too.
I'm planning on going back to the mall on Monday, probably going to get Keith Urban's new album, maybe get an actual copy of Tim McGraw's Greatest Hits this time, and get Carrie Underwood's Carnival Ride. Still trying to decide what album(s) I should get from Brad Paisley and Sugarland.
Thank you so much again for the recommendations, I really appreciate it! I wanted to get into country but I hadn't made much progress with actually finding any until you gave me the list of recommendations to go through, and I'm really glad I've got a pretty good start on some country music.