I generally avoid character forums unless I've been told about some match-up altering thing that deserves investigating. See, some character boards are so chocked full of bias and fanboyism that it really puts me off of them. This is most common in the lower tier character boards.
Fanboism, Yes. Biased, Not even close, and this is what you have to get over. Nobody ever goes around shouting whatever they want and recording it on some half baked chart. Every chart I have seen always discuss things through. They look into what their character has, and how they fare against the character they're discussing. Most importantly though, they actually get people of the repersenting discussed character to debate with. No Chart is biased, and if they are, then they get completely called upon by the community. Bias does not exist in the character boards, It's all in your thick head.
Plus I find it hard to believe that you call us biased when 2/3's of our Matchups are agreed upon by the repersenting matchup thread. We agree that we are neutral with MetaKnight\, and MetaKnight's have agreed with us that we are neutral. So how are we Biased when BOTH PARTIES AGREE ON THE RATIO OF THE MATCHUP!?
By the way, when going on about how my chart is the fifth horseman of the apocalypse, please at least state ONE match-up that you believe is inaccurate. Criticism is important but there's not much 'improvement' I can do unless you tell me specifically what's bothering you.
Honestly though, I can name probably 50 Matchups that are inaccurate, excluding Yoshi's, which I have honestly given up on trying to convince you. When I give you a list of what matchups are wrong on Yoshi's side (Which is almost 3/4's!) With about half of them agreed by both parties, You only changed one matchup. The bigger blow is that the one matchup you changed was
NOT one of the matchups I presented, making it even
MORE inaccurate!
This is why people don't like your Chart, because whenever people point out the flaws, you just completely ignore them altogether. You don't seem to realize that this thread you are running is (Or rather used to be) a Major Completive Outlet. You made it for an reference to help people, but how helpful would it be when most of the characters matchups are over 40% wrong?
My little quip on the Yoshi/Metaknight thingy (that I will never change until I believe it): Given that in the SBR-style counterpicking system you can always change your character every round, why isn't Yoshi popping up as everybody's secondary? I mean, if Yoshi himself has a bunch of bad match-ups (which is the reason for him not showing up to challenge Metaknights everywhere, right?) why not just switch him out for your primary character when your opponent doesn't pick Metaknight? If you lose to a Metaknight first round you get to first pick a level (FD or whatever other flat one for the chain grabs) then, if your opponent sticks with Metaknight you pick Yoshi. If next round you believe that you'll be against an anti-Yoshi, you switch out.
I don't think you realize how Technical and Complex Yoshi is to use as an character. You need to Learn how:
- His Recovery Works
- To use grabs and attacks as an alternative Defence
- To combo in the air
- His projectile works, and learn proper aiming
- To combo/chaingrab out of release
- To combo with Bair
- To hit with Uair
- To Punish without Shields
- To use his multiple AT's to improve moves such as his Pivot Grab's and Eggs
- To use Escapes
- To Block Projectiles with attacks
This is the bare minimum you need to know just to be decent with him. There are some more stuff I left out such as DR's and Dthrow Tech Chasing, but my point is that Yoshi isn't a character that someone can just pick up and start slaughtering with him. This is what people need to understand.
It also doesn't help that people like you keep telling everyone that he is completely garbage, and a waste of time.