• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Official Brawl Tier Discussion (OP Updated)

Status
Not open for further replies.

NESSBOUNDER

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
3,167
Location
somewhere sunny
I really think people should be considering Mr. Game and Watch and Pikachu to go somewhere inside top tier.

Toon Link...I'm not so sure about him any more. I used to think he was the best character in the game, but I realise that a lot of his best KO moves (Fsmash particularly) don't have as much range or speed as you'd hope, and many of them are unsafe on block. In fact, a lot of his moves are suprisingly unsafe on block I find. I'd still say he's in the top tier, but Mr. Game and Watch should certainly be higher due to his insane...everything.

People really seem to be underestimating Pikachu. If you think aobut it, what weaknesses does Pikachu really have? He has plenty of range and priority on his attacks, even the non-disjointed ones. He has very little lag on just about everyhing, including thunder, which is just a nasty, nasty KO move now against everyone but those with reflectors. He has plenty of ways to close in on campers (Quack, crawling, etc.) and has a projectile of his own which can get very annoying. Oh yes, and he's frikkin' POWERFUL too.

I could say the same for Mr. Game and Watch on most accounts. His only weakness is that he's light. Besides that, he has excellent hitboxes, great approaches, great shield pressure, great power, a great deterrant against energy projectiles...which accounts for some of the most commonly spammed attacks from popular characters, ie lasers, Palutena arrows, PK Fires.

You'll also find most Lucas players being very modest about their character and placing him in mid or high tiers. Since the top tier list can't be too big or else that'd be redundant, Lucas should defintely be near the top of high for many of the same reasons Mr Game and Watch and Pikachu are good. He's very fast, very tricky, has loads and loads of options and advanced techniques to play with, awesome recovery, super powerful smash attacks, even the fast ones, and he has not one, but TWO ways to deal with incoming projectiles of any kind, as well as a pseudo-pillar that eats away at shields. He also has landing Nair combos, and one of the most lethal edge guarding projectiles in the game. And up smash, which is pretty much like detonating an Ike Fsmash all around your character, one that hits twice and is very hard to air dodge while coming down. He also has priority and disjointed hitboxes...lol, as if the rest wasn't enough. And as of now, frame data suggests that his jab combo's initial hitbox comes out on FRAME 1. Shine plz?
 

BDawgPHD

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 1, 2007
Messages
751
I really think people should be considering Mr. Game and Watch and Pikachu to go somewhere inside top tier.

Toon Link...I'm not so sure about him any more. I used to think he was the best character in the game, but I realise that a lot of his best KO moves (Fsmash particularly) don't have as much range or speed as you'd hope, and many of them are unsafe on block. In fact, a lot of his moves are suprisingly unsafe on block I find. I'd still say he's in the top tier, but Mr. Game and Watch should certainly be higher due to his insane...everything.

People really seem to be underestimating Pikachu. If you think aobut it, what weaknesses does Pikachu really have? He has plenty of range and priority on his attacks, even the non-disjointed ones. He has very little lag on just about everyhing, including thunder, which is just a nasty, nasty KO move now against everyone but those with reflectors. He has plenty of ways to close in on campers (Quack, crawling, etc.) and has a projectile of his own which can get very annoying. Oh yes, and he's frikkin' POWERFUL too.

I could say the same for Mr. Game and Watch on most accounts. His only weakness is that he's light. Besides that, he has excellent hitboxes, great approaches, great shield pressure, great power, a great deterrant against energy projectiles...which accounts for some of the most commonly spammed attacks from popular characters, ie lasers, Palutena arrows, PK Fires.

You'll also find most Lucas players being very modest about their character and placing him in mid or high tiers. Since the top tier list can't be too big or else that'd be redundant, Lucas should defintely be near the top of high for many of the same reasons Mr Game and Watch and Pikachu are good. He's very fast, very tricky, has loads and loads of options and advanced techniques to play with, awesome recovery, super powerful smash attacks, even the fast ones, and he has not one, but TWO ways to deal with incoming projectiles of any kind, as well as a pseudo-pillar that eats away at shields. He also has landing Nair combos, and one of the most lethal edge guarding projectiles in the game. And up smash, which is pretty much like detonating an Ike Fsmash all around your character, one that hits twice and is very hard to air dodge while coming down. He also has priority and disjointed hitboxes...lol, as if the rest wasn't enough. And as of now, frame data suggests that his jab combo's initial hitbox comes out on FRAME 1. Shine plz?
I've already been saying that Pikachu is easily top tier, he's almost as broken as MK or Snake....maybe even more broken than MK, considering his lack of lag, projectiles, and destructive combos. I don't know exactly how good G&W is, seeing as how I spend most of my time using the hammer :3, but I know he's better than he was in Melee, and is actually a good character. I just haven't really put him to the test yet. As for the little fudgehead, I don't know him well enough to speak highly of him, but I know he can be a pain in the butt.

P.S. Bowser's fair is godly.
 

mesCo

Smash Cadet
Joined
Mar 29, 2008
Messages
27
Location
Connecticut
yea g&w is good, but i think olimar is decent too. The thing is... i can never tell which move they are doing so i always get pissed off, especially against olimar. His side b, side smash, and grab all look so similar to me, although i dont have much experience with him.
 

PIMPSLAP

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Messages
1,189
Location
Snakes BAIR
yea g&w is good, but i think olimar is decent too. The thing is... i can never tell which move they are doing so i always get pissed off, especially against olimar. His side b, side smash, and grab all look so similar to me, although i don't have much experience with him.
lol to kill olimar
follow these steps.
1. knock olimar off stage
2. grab ledge before he pushes up-b
3. he dies:)
to gishnak and that other guy thanks my list would be changing but there is to much flaming and noobs sorry i said it but there are noobs in here but hey thats why i stop posting in here. thanks again for your support i backed it as much as i could but failed
 

PIMPSLAP

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Messages
1,189
Location
Snakes BAIR
who wins tournaments in scotland???Pidgey? like the top character over there i know that japan is different from us so u might be different.
 

Corner-Trap

Smash Ace
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
Messages
535
Location
Fayetteville, NC
Honestly, enough with this Bowser being high tier crap, he simply isn't. Until people start listing match-ups where he's at an advantage against, I'll never believe he's anywhere past low tier. Sure he's been buffed since Melee and has a few new tricks, but they don't amount to much when compared to what the majority of other characters can do. In short, post up a match-up chart for Bowser showing that he actually has any good matches.
 

pidgey14

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Apr 1, 2008
Messages
103
Location
Dundee, Scotland
NNID
Redpidgey
I am just saying that there is a huge debate going on in this thread. I am just asking, can't we all just wait for an official Tier list instead. I doubt that everyone has played every character fairly. People are putting the ones on the bottom, that they probably have never given a chance, and believing someone, who ain't pro so that means to the person that the character "sucks" and at "bottom."
 

Corner-Trap

Smash Ace
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
Messages
535
Location
Fayetteville, NC
How bout you just stop posting in this thread since you obviously don't want to contribute to the conversation and let everyone else carry about their business and not worry about it?
 

MiraiGen

Smash Ace
Joined
Sep 23, 2006
Messages
710
You can't post in an extremely active topic and go, "Look, we obviously aren't making the decision, so give up."

You can't just tell us we're not supposed to care or argue about it. We'll decide for ourselves because we like speculating. Why else do you think that all the Blizzard Forums people are debating so actively about Wrath of the Lich King and what it's going to have? Because they're curious and it's fun.
 

pidgey14

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Apr 1, 2008
Messages
103
Location
Dundee, Scotland
NNID
Redpidgey
Yeah all just go for me. thank you very much. I just try to explain something then you are all going at me. I wonder why you are all flaming me, and not anyone else who say the same thing as me...
 

BDawgPHD

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 1, 2007
Messages
751
Honestly, enough with this Bowser being high tier crap, he simply isn't. Until people start listing match-ups where he's at an advantage against, I'll never believe he's anywhere past low tier. Sure he's been buffed since Melee and has a few new tricks, but they don't amount to much when compared to what the majority of other characters can do. In short, post up a match-up chart for Bowser showing that he actually has any good matches.
I'd suggest that you try Bowser yourself, but you're nub, and clearly don't know anyone good, so that would just be out of the question.

The only bad matchups he has that I can think of are Falco (chainthrow to spike), Kirby (drillstomp to footstool), and possibly DK (about as much range and strength and has a spike). None of these are terrible matchups by any means, and he's otherwise a very good character due to his gross speed, range, and strength. Why don't you explain some serious problems with Bowser.....why low tier? Why do you think he's so bad when he's clearly very good?
 

Corner-Trap

Smash Ace
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
Messages
535
Location
Fayetteville, NC
I'd suggest that you try Bowser yourself, but you're nub, and clearly don't know anyone good, so that would just be out of the question.

The only bad matchups he has that I can think of are Falco (chainthrow to spike), Kirby (drillstomp to footstool), and possibly DK (about as much range and strength and has a spike). None of these are terrible matchups by any means, and he's otherwise a very good character due to his gross speed, range, and strength. Why don't you explain some serious problems with Bowser.....why low tier? Why do you think he's so bad when he's clearly very good?
Guess we're back to our old ways again :chuckle: Most characters have a slight advantage against him, while he doesn't really have much advantage over anyone. At best he goes even against some characters. So how can a character with no notably good match-ups possibly be high tier? And you know something is wrong when Bowser mains even disagree with him being anywhere near high tier. Why do you think he's so good when he clearly doesn't have many good match-ups?
 

Griffard

Smash Ace
Joined
Sep 13, 2007
Messages
748
Location
Geneva, IL/New Orleans, LA
another way to find a list is to narrow it down to 3 or so groups of completely accepted things in literally no order. high, low, and confused/debated? i think that might help. this just suggests spectrums, not specific lists.
In literally NO ORDER
HIGH: Toon Link, Marth, Olimar, Snake, Mr. Game and Watch, Wolf, Falco, R.O.B., Metaknight
LOW: Sonic, Captain Falcon, Ganondorf, Yoshi, Jigglypuff
DEBATED: Every other char is talked about for high or low, and is either not commonly agreed upon or is simply in the middle area.
 

Gindler

Smash Champion
Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
2,442
Location
Orlando (UCF)
I'd suggest that you try Bowser yourself, but you're nub, and clearly don't know anyone good, so that would just be out of the question.

The only bad matchups he has that I can think of are Falco (chainthrow to spike), Kirby (drillstomp to footstool), and possibly DK (about as much range and strength and has a spike). None of these are terrible matchups by any means, and he's otherwise a very good character due to his gross speed, range, and strength. Why don't you explain some serious problems with Bowser.....why low tier? Why do you think he's so bad when he's clearly very good?
Oh, you seem to have left out yoshi's flutter kick to footstool (alot like kirby's but alot easier to pull off the footstool and it's more damaging of an attack as well)
 

Corigames

Smash Hero
Joined
Oct 20, 2006
Messages
5,817
Location
Tempe, AZ
What is this thread for? At first I thought, this was to discuss threads, but now it is just to see who can make the most ******** tier list. Here's mine:

God:
Yoshi

High:
Falcon
Peach
Link
DK

Mid:
Ganon
Fox
Trainer
Mario
Luigi
Bowser

Low:
Everyone else
 

Gindler

Smash Champion
Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
2,442
Location
Orlando (UCF)
(the order in the tiers do no nessarily suggest order)
Top
Metaknight
Snake
Marth

High
Luigi
Toon Link
G&W
Wolf
Falco
ROB
Lucas
IC

Mid
Mario
Ike
King Dedede
Olimar
Link
Pokemon Trainer
Pikachu
Kirby
Fox
Bowser
Zelda
Pit
Ness
Diddy

Low
Shiek
Lucario
Zamus
Donkey Kong
Wario
Jiggs
Sonic

Bottom
Samus
Ganon
C. Falcon
Yoshi
Ha, yoshi's not the worst in the game. and the previous post, Yoshi is good but definetly not GOD tier even though his combos are destructive and easy to pull off.
 

BDawgPHD

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 1, 2007
Messages
751
Well, his good matchups I'd say are against characters without projectiles, for the sole reason that they have to outrange Bowser, which is reasonably hard for someone that isn't Ike. Bowser has quick, powerful, RANGED attacks, making him pretty ****ing dangerous. He's a big target for projectiles, but that's all. If you know how to avoid projectiles, it doesn't matter as much. Bowser has some decent approach options against campers, but doesn't have to be aggressive against anybody....actually, his defensive game is amazing, just because of his beast tilts and his good grabs. And on top of that, Bowser is sort of his own WoP, just because of his range and speed. You can try to land on the ground and get tilted. You can try to jump and get faired. You can try to attack and get out-prioritized/out-ranged. The only thing you can do is run away, for the most part, unless you have an attack that has more priority or range.

Seriously, learn to play Brawl. Brawl isn't Melee. In Melee, Bowser was low/bottom because he was a huge slow ****ing target, not because he was bad. In Brawl, he's still a huge target, but combos aren't as prevalent, although they do show up more on Bowser and DK than on most others. His speed isn't as much of a problem because

a) this isn't Melee, this is Brawl....spacing and camping are a lot more important than speed.

b) his speed was buffed greatly.....his footspeed is meh, and his smash attacks are laggy, but his tilts and jab combo are godly fast, his side-B is much quicker and much more versatile, and his aerials aren't so slow, although you'll have to mindgame people to hit some of them.

If you keep this in mind, and you take your time and just space people out with Bowser, you'll realize that he's just generally a beast. I say high tier...he won't go below high tier, but he won't be top tier, either.


P.S. Everyone knows that

God Tier:
Snake
Meta Knight
(Pikachu? doubt it, but he is pretty broken)

Order is still up for debate, but I'll put Snake up top because he counters MK.
 

Dingding123

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Sep 27, 2007
Messages
478
Location
Houston, TX
I find it quite awesome that u can pwn with literally ANY character. No four or five characters are ridiculously better than all the rest anymore. Now it's more like there's 15 or so characters that are, overall, a little better than the rest of them.
 

VulgarHandGestures

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Mar 18, 2008
Messages
326
bdawg, awhile back you said you would fight anyone who thought bowser wasn't high tier material? my friend code is 1375-6977-5352. i've never met anyone who made bowser look good.

the same thing goes to anyone who thinks game and watch belongs in top tier. he doesn't. i'll accept if you feel like you can prove me wrong.
 

Corner-Trap

Smash Ace
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
Messages
535
Location
Fayetteville, NC
BDawgPHD

So you say that Bowser's good match-ups are against characters with no projectiels? Well here's a list of characters with absolutely no projectiles:

Marth
Metaknight
Ike
Donkey Kong
Jigglypuff
Wario
Sonic
Captain Falcon
Gannondorf

As you can see, thats a fairly small list. Even with that handful of characters Bowser is still at a disadvantage to some while only getting a fair match-up at best against others. How about you simply list which characters in specific you think Bowser has an advantage against?

EDIT:

On a side note Bowsers approach, camping, edgeguarding, recovery, ground game, and aerial game are all below average. I can list several characters who can out do him in all of those areas.
 

TehBo49

Smash Ace
Joined
Feb 14, 2008
Messages
589
Location
In an alternate universe, where Brawl does not suc
-_- can't we not just wait for an official tier list? cuz most of them are just not right.
Honestly, no we can't. Everyone on SWF is obsessed with tier lists & if it weren't for this thread, the boards would be overflowing with endless "Rate My Tier List" threads. If your one of the few people who are immune to tiermania, then I suggest that you simply ignore this thread as you'll never be able to convince us to wait.

Now, here's my new tier list. While I don't know everything about every character, I've done some research & I think my list is somewhat accurate. Feel free to comment; I'll do my best to defend this list.

**TOP TIER**
Snake
Lucas
Toon Link
Mr. G&W
Pikachu
**HIGH TIER**
Falco
Meta Knight
Wolf
Olimar
ROB
Marth
**UPPER MIDDLE TIER**
Pit
King Dedede
Ice Climbers
Luigi
Kirby
ZSS
Zelda
Fox
**LOWER MIDDLE TIER**
Ness
Wario
Lucario
Samus
Diddy Kong
Squritle
Sheik
Ike
**LOW TIER**
Ivysaur
Mario
Donkey Kong
Peach
Bowser
Charizard
Sonic
**BOTTOM TIER**
Link
Yoshi
Jigglypuff
Ganondorf
Captain Falcon
 

Gindler

Smash Champion
Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
2,442
Location
Orlando (UCF)
Honestly, no we can't. Everyone on SWF is obsessed with tier lists & if it weren't for this thread, the boards would be overflowing with endless "Rate My Tier List" threads. If your one of the few people who are immune to tiermania, then I suggest that you simply ignore this thread as you'll never be able to convince us to wait.

Now, here's my new tier list. While I don't know everything about every character, I've done some research & I think my list is somewhat accurate. Feel free to comment; I'll do my best to defend this list.

**TOP TIER**
Snake
Lucas
Toon Link
Mr. G&W
Pikachu
**HIGH TIER**
Falco
Meta Knight
Wolf
Olimar
ROB
Marth
**UPPER MIDDLE TIER**
Pit
King Dedede
Ice Climbers
Luigi
Kirby
ZSS
Zelda
Fox
**LOWER MIDDLE TIER**
Ness
Wario
Lucario
Samus
Diddy Kong
Squritle
Sheik
Ike
**LOW TIER**
Ivysaur
Mario
Donkey Kong
Peach
Bowser
Charizard
Sonic
**BOTTOM TIER**
Link
Yoshi
Jigglypuff
Ganondorf
Captain Falcon
Top tier lucas? His recovery is too gimpable (not as much as ness but still pretty easy) but I'd but him in the lower of the high tier.

Oh and may I ask why you put yoshi in bottom tier? the other bottoms I agree cause of their nerfs but yoshi's been pretty buffed in terms of comboing and edgeguardging.
 

BDawgPHD

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 1, 2007
Messages
751
BDawgPHD

So you say that Bowser's good match-ups are against characters with no projectiels? Well here's a list of characters with absolutely no projectiles:

Marth
Metaknight
Ike
Donkey Kong
Jigglypuff
Wario
Sonic
Captain Falcon
Gannondorf

As you can see, thats a fairly small list. Even with that handful of characters Bowser is still at a disadvantage to some while only getting a fair match-up at best against others. How about you simply list which characters in specific you think Bowser has an advantage against?

EDIT:

On a side note Bowsers approach, camping, edgeguarding, recovery, ground game, and aerial game are all below average. I can list several characters who can out do him in all of those areas.
Bowser's approach isn't very bad, depending on who you're playing against. His ground game is amazing, arguably one of the best ground games out of all the characters, save Snake, whose ground game is just broken. His aerial game isn't bad, although his fair is the only awesome attack that isn't easily airdodged away from. His uair has amazing range and is deceitfully fast, like his fsmash. His vertical recovery isn't good enough to save himself after getting footstooled unless he has his second jump in reserve, but his recovery is otherwise pretty good, and he still needs to be off the ledge in order to get gimped in that way. His camping in the sense of spamming projectiles and forcing players to approach is nonexistent, considering he only has flame breath. However, as far as camping outside of a character's range, waiting for said character to intercept his own range, Bowser's camping is amazing due to his great range and speed. His edgeguarding is actually very good....he doesn't have killing options for edgeguarding, but he has a lot of damage/fear tactics. His flame breath goes under the stage, and although it only stuns and won't really kill anyone besides Pit or Jiggs, it'll still tack on a good 10-30% extra damage, which is brutal when playing against Bowser. Also, his fsmash hits under the stage, so you're basically forced to get off the ledge....if you don't, you pretty much die. If you do, hopefully you remembered to attack from the ledge.

I don't see why he's at a disadvantage against Sonic, who has abominable range, and aside from MK, who is broken, and Ike, who outranges him and doesn't seem to have any other big advantage on him anyway, how could any of those characters get any sort of leverage on Bowser?
 

VulgarHandGestures

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Mar 18, 2008
Messages
326
i swear to god, if i were given the chance, i'd strangle every person who keeps splitting up the pokemon trainer. IT'S ONE ****ING CHARACTER YOU STUPID SLUTS.
 

PIMPSLAP

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Messages
1,189
Location
Snakes BAIR
PIMPSLAP please explain to me why Bowser is low tier:)
Sure no problem
Bowser cons:

1.Boswer being Giant= easy to hit,tip,camp,grab,gimp,footstool,suck up,
2. Boswer being slow= camp mind games,reach mind games,smash mind games.all against bowser.
3. no camping ability.
4. slow start up and ending lag on most attacks.
5. Moves have low prioty
6. NO GOOD MATCH UPS.
7. recovery very gimp able,punishable, for see able, predictable , and Stoppable
8. Out reached easy enough
9. easy to approach
10. easy to get away from
11. doesn't have alot mindgames.(excluding GimpyFish) he's cool and does not apply to this list.
12. Predictable attacks.
13. easy to shield grab
14. does not punish well
15. smashes are easy to dodge except the D-smash.
16. Tilts are moderate at best.
17. fire is predictable and punishable
18. When most characters dodge one of bowser attacks that most likely means they will get a successfully smash on him.
19. easiest character to put c4 on.
20. easiest character to glide toss on.
21. one of the easiest character to ice climbers chain grab to.
22. has 1 decent aerial.
23. punished in the ai
22. has 1 decent aerial.
23. punished in the air just for going in the air by almost every character but like 3 or 4.
24. light jumps sometimes don't cancel(might be my problem on this one)
26. Mario beats him in all the games but like 2.:)


Pros:
1. Has bowser side which is harder to do then early sense people can stop it know by holding the directional button toward the opposite way.
2. has that cool little infinite jump cancel(i suck at it:) )
3. Looks AWESOME.
4........

Sorry bdawg all these things work against or are bowser weakness and flaws thats why he's low tier.:)
BUT FOR YOU I WILL HAVE A BOWSER AVATAR!:)
 

St. Viers

Smash Champion
Joined
May 15, 2006
Messages
2,409
Location
Boston MA
Corner Trap said:
Originally Posted by Corner-Trap View Post
BDawgPHD

So you say that Bowser's good match-ups are against characters with no projectiels? Well here's a list of characters with absolutely no projectiles:

Marth
Metaknight
Ike
Donkey Kong
Jigglypuff
Wario
Sonic
Captain Falcon
Gannondorf

As you can see, thats a fairly small list. Even with that handful of characters Bowser is still at a disadvantage to some while only getting a fair match-up at best against others. How about you simply list which characters in specific you think Bowser has an advantage against?

EDIT:

On a side note Bowsers approach, camping, edgeguarding, recovery, ground game, and aerial game are all below average. I can list several characters who can out do him in all of those areas.
Also, bowser's jab, f-tilt and flame breath own many projectiles, making him not get owned too hard by people other than falco, wolf, and snake.

But anywho:

Bowser> Ike. I'm not joking. He can easily gimp Ike's recovery, and the only thing to worry about is staying out of Ike's jab range, and watching out for side B approaching.

Bowser> Falcon, Ganon, Wario, Sonic. Obvious reasons.

Bowser=Jiggz, DK

Bowser<Marth, but less than people think

Bowser<MK, by alot.

But regarding his game:

Approaching: It's decent. His f-air has almost no lag if performed properly, and dashing into shield is great for him, as he can dash to outside their grab range and simply shield-drop->f-tilt. His SH fire isn't a great approach, but it's decent. Also, as he can deal with many projectiles, and has a great ledge game, (though not as good as melee), he can simply camp. I'd say his approach game is like 5.5/10

Camping: Again average, or a bit better. Thanks to quick, almost disjointed jabs he doen't need to worry about many projectiles, and his OOS game is excellent. Add platforms and ledges and his camping game only gets better. 7-8/10

Edgeguarding: How is it below average? his f-air is great, and if they airdodge you can just jump and f-air again, or b-air, or just side-B. He can also just use fire to prevent them from grabbing the edge, by jumping and angling it down. So um yeah...also remember that edge-guarding isn't as major an aspect in this game. 5/10

Recovery: Agreed. It isn't bad, but it isn't good. However, Bowsers weight plus DI equal lasting long regardless.

Ground Game: Are you high? his jab, f-tilt, d-tilt, all are excellent. His up tilt is fast and covers behind him. He can punish laggy attacks/rolls&techs&spotdodges with his up and down smash. Shield drop to F-smash works on laggy attacks against the shield, and OOS upB deals with the less laggy attacks. He has great range, for not having a sword, and his fire can easily rack up 30 damage. It can do more against heavier characters/worse players. Simply put, your wrong about his ground game. the shield physics alone aid him tons

Air Game: I agree with you. Excepting his f-air, his aerials are pretty much only useful for pressure. If you know your opponent will shield, his d-air is good as it will almost always poke, but otherwise it sucks.

So pretty much although bowser isn't great, he is better than you (and many others) give him credit for. I call it post-melee syndrome ;)
 

Corner-Trap

Smash Ace
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
Messages
535
Location
Fayetteville, NC
The point of my previous post was to counter BDawgPHD's statement. He said that Bowser has good match-ups against characters without projectiles, so I posted a list of all the characters without projectiles, which happens to only be a handful. Even with that small number of characters you can see that Bowser is at a disadvantage to some while only going even with others. So we can hardly generalize saying that Bowser has good match-ups against characters without projectiles. When I said that Bowser's approach, camping, edgeguarding, recovery, ground game, and air game were all below average, I was saying that in comparison to other characters. Sure you can list a few tricks he has that may make him seem decent in those areas, but when compared to the options other characters have in those areas he's only below average. I think Bowser will be low tier at least, or mid tier at most, but most definitely not high tier as BDawgPHD is trying to suggest.
 

St. Viers

Smash Champion
Joined
May 15, 2006
Messages
2,409
Location
Boston MA
Sure no problem
Bowser cons:

1.Boswer being Giant= easy to hit,tip,camp,grab,gimp,footstool,suck up,
2. Boswer being slow= camp mind games,reach mind games,smash mind games.all against bowser.
3. no camping ability.
4. slow start up and ending lag on most attacks.
5. Moves have low prioty
6. NO GOOD MATCH UPS.
7. recovery very gimp able,punishable, for see able, predictable , and Stoppable
8. Out reached easy enough
9. easy to approach
10. easy to get away from
11. doesn't have alot mindgames.(excluding GimpyFish) he's cool and does not apply to this list.
12. Predictable attacks.
13. easy to shield grab
14. does not punish well
15. smashes are easy to dodge except the D-smash.
16. Tilts are moderate at best.
17. fire is predictable and punishable
18. When most characters dodge one of bowser attacks that most likely means they will get a successfully smash on him.
19. easiest character to put c4 on.
20. easiest character to glide toss on.
21. one of the easiest character to ice climbers chain grab to.
22. has 1 decent aerial.
23. punished in the ai
22. has 1 decent aerial.
23. punished in the air just for going in the air by almost every character but like 3 or 4.
24. light jumps sometimes don't cancel(might be my problem on this one)
26. Mario beats him in all the games but like 2.:)


Pros:
1. Has bowser side which is harder to do then early sense people can stop it know by holding the directional button toward the opposite way.
2. has that cool little infinite jump cancel(i suck at it:) )
3. Looks AWESOME.
4........

Sorry bdawg all these things work against or are bowser weakness and flaws thats why he's low tier.:)
BUT FOR YOU I WILL HAVE A BOWSER AVATAR!:)
1. Bowser is big and heavy, meaning he lasts longer.
2.Bowser isn't that slow. And his attacks definately aren't
3.read my post above. His OOS shield game is excellent, and his ledge game is decent enough.
4. Um, have you actually played bowser in brawl? I think not.
5. Um, hve you used bowsers ground attacks in brawl...I think not.
6. Wrong. read my above post.
7.True
8.wrong. his f-tilt and fire outrange most people.
9.wrong. please explain that one
10. no easier than anyone else.
11. Not true. Mind games are player specific, not character. The new shield system gives bowser plenty of options
12. only olimar hsa unpredictable attacks.
13. nt really, unless they try shffling attacks at you (put thats true about 90% of aerials in this game) He can just dash-shield, f-tilt/d-tilt poke you from outside your grab range.
14. Um, his smashes are like the definition of punish.
15. You use smashes to punish, not just randomly throw out. Why open yourself when you can kill with f-tilt, upB, up-air, f-air, and u tilt?
16. Tilts are excellent. speed, range and power, and up-tilt reaches behind him.
17. True, but again, true of most things by all characters. And it is a great edgeguard if you use it right (read above), and if you hit it will deal at least 20 damage, with the possibility of more if the opponent is heavy/dumb.
18. Untrue. Only if you throw out aerials and smashes. However, because people think this I bait f-air to jab all the time...f-air autocancels if performed properly
19. but that's the least of bowsers worries against snake. Most people have horriblt matchups against snake anyways.
20. You can grab most things that are being tossed at you easily, or just shield them. This point was an example of you trying to wow us with your terminology (and failing)
21. Again, IC are hard anyways, and they still have to grab you for that to work.
22. he has 1 good aerial (f-air) 2 decent (u-air, n-air), and two situational ones (d/b-air)
23. so don't go the air needlessly. Also, airdodge system makes it less bad.
24. That is you.
26. He let mario win ^_^

Seriously, you seem to be saying things based on untruths and popular misconceptions.

Sorry for the double post, but I felt it necessary ^_^

C_Trap said:
The point of my previous post was to counter BDawgPHD's statement. He said that Bowser has good match-ups against characters without projectiles, so I posted a list of all the characters without projectiles, which happens to only be a handful. Even with that small number of characters you can see that Bowser is at a disadvantage to some while only going even with others. So we can hardly generalize saying that Bowser has good match-ups against characters without projectiles. When I said that Bowser's approach, camping, edgeguarding, recovery, ground game, and air game were all below average, I was saying that in comparison to other characters. Sure you can list a few tricks he has that may make him seem decent in those areas, but when compared to the options other characters have in those areas he's only below average. I think Bowser will be low tier at least, or mid tier at most, but most definitely not high tier as BDawgPHD is trying to suggest.
I see your point, as bdawg was exaggerating a bit, but bowser still has good amtchups in general against people without projectiles, and people with unspammable one. Also, I AM saying you are wrong about his camping, ground games. his ground game should be undeniably excellent, and his camping is again above par. They aren't little tricks that make him decent. They are extra options that most people don't have, which make him *better* at them than others. That's like saying projectile camping is a little trick to make someone decent at camping, or saying that using auto-cancel aerials is a trick to make marth, MK better at approaching. it's kinda true, but put in a way to OBVIOUSLY belittle it.
 

TehBo49

Smash Ace
Joined
Feb 14, 2008
Messages
589
Location
In an alternate universe, where Brawl does not suc
Top tier lucas? His recovery is too gimpable (not as much as ness but still pretty easy) but I'd but him in the lower of the high tier.

Oh and may I ask why you put yoshi in bottom tier? the other bottoms I agree cause of their nerfs but yoshi's been pretty buffed in terms of comboing and edgeguardging.
Lucas is top tier for many reasons. He has an awesome aerial game, an awesome ground game, three projectiles (2 of which are very good), disjointed hitboxes, a way to absorb projectiles, good edgeguarding, tether recovery, & great range (especially u-smash). Recovery is gimpable but not terrible.

Yoshi is one of those characters that I'm not too knowledgable about. The reason I put him in bottom tier is because he really doesn't have any standout good qualities. His ground game is about average, his aerial game is decent, his range is about average, he has an okay projectile, & his recovery is the most predictable in the game. If you can give me some more information on Yoshi, I could move him up but so far I don't see any reason for him to be any higher than low tier.
 

PIMPSLAP

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Messages
1,189
Location
Snakes BAIR
1. Bowser is big and heavy, meaning he lasts longer.
2.Bowser isn't that slow. And his attacks definately aren't
3.read my post above. His OOS shield game is excellent, and his ledge game is decent enough.
4. Um, have you actually played bowser in brawl? I think not.
5. Um, hve you used bowsers ground attacks in brawl...I think not.
6. Wrong. read my above post.
7.True
8.wrong. his f-tilt and fire outrange most people.
9.wrong. please explain that one
10. no easier than anyone else.
11. Not true. Mind games are player specific, not character. The new shield system gives bowser plenty of options
12. only olimar hsa unpredictable attacks.
13. nt really, unless they try shffling attacks at you (put thats true about 90% of aerials in this game) He can just dash-shield, f-tilt/d-tilt poke you from outside your grab range.
14. Um, his smashes are like the definition of punish.
15. You use smashes to punish, not just randomly throw out. Why open yourself when you can kill with f-tilt, upB, up-air, f-air, and u tilt?
16. Tilts are excellent. speed, range and power, and up-tilt reaches behind him.
17. True, but again, true of most things by all characters. And it is a great edgeguard if you use it right (read above), and if you hit it will deal at least 20 damage, with the possibility of more if the opponent is heavy/dumb.
18. Untrue. Only if you throw out aerials and smashes. However, because people think this I bait f-air to jab all the time...f-air autocancels if performed properly
19. but that's the least of bowsers worries against snake. Most people have horriblt matchups against snake anyways.
20. You can grab most things that are being tossed at you easily, or just shield them. This point was an example of you trying to wow us with your terminology (and failing)
21. Again, IC are hard anyways, and they still have to grab you for that to work.
22. he has 1 good aerial (f-air) 2 decent (u-air, n-air), and two situational ones (d/b-air)
23. so don't go the air needlessly. Also, airdodge system makes it less bad.
24. That is you.
26. He let mario win ^_^

Seriously, you seem to be saying things based on untruths and popular misconceptions.

Sorry for the double post, but I felt it necessary ^_^
ok guy all my stuff is factual and you are just biased i respect you sticking up for bowser and presenting pretty decent facts i ask you one quetion and only one question will bowser evr be high or top tier my friend i apologize for that post i was in some cases trying to emphasize on he's weaknesses. props for defending your fav character:)
i like your response to 26
also i will add you to the ever narrow list of smart bowser players.:)(being funny)
 

Gindler

Smash Champion
Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
2,442
Location
Orlando (UCF)
Lucas is top tier for many reasons. He has an awesome aerial game, an awesome ground game, three projectiles (2 of which are very good), disjointed hitboxes, a way to absorb projectiles, good edgeguarding, tether recovery, & great range (especially u-smash). Recovery is gimpable but not terrible.

Yoshi is one of those characters that I'm not too knowledgable about. The reason I put him in bottom tier is because he really doesn't have any standout good qualities. His ground game is about average, his aerial game is decent, his range is about average, he has an okay projectile, & his recovery is the most predictable in the game. If you can give me some more information on Yoshi, I could move him up but so far I don't see any reason for him to be any higher than low tier.
True Lucas does have a good aerial game but just about any lucas and ness main will tell you ness's is alot more superior to lucas's. Ness has 3 projectiles as well but you only put him on low mid tier (then again only 1 is that great, another iffy one that stuns, and a useless slow but powerful one) True his smashes are great too, but all are easily UBER punishable besides his stick, the tether recovery is great but his grab is slow (even slower than a non pivot grab from yoshi)

I don't blaim you on the yoshi thing, no one seems to know anything about him and everyone who doesn't use him or have played a good one will put him on bottom tier. True his smashes aren't all that great, Dsmash nerf, Upsmash nerf, but his up and forward smash all have a dodging quality when he initiates them do to he leans his head back making him alot smaller target and he can dodge other smashes and punish by doing this. Oh and his aerial game is alot more than decent, I'm sure if you asked alot of people who've played a good yoshi would say his aerial game is probably top 5 do to they are all useful. True his projectile is alot more dificult than most but he can juggle people recovering with it easily. His recovery is awfully predictable do to no real recovery move it's more like a stall with distance but if you time his second jump as your being attacked you get juggernaut frames and fly right through it. His best qualities are probably his awesome edgeguarding game, and the fact his Bair combos into ANYTHING even smashes, and it shield pokes so there's no way around being hit.
 

St. Viers

Smash Champion
Joined
May 15, 2006
Messages
2,409
Location
Boston MA
actually, G&W is my favorite character, followed by wario, kirby, IC, fox, luigi, ROB and pikachu. I just main bowser.

I have no illuions on how good/bad bowser is. I'm merely prenting facts. If I had frame data I'd use it, but as it is just trust that my approach to both brawl and debates is based on amassing knowledge. Your "facts" were for the most part wrong, and presented in an obviously biased way.

As to your question, the answer is hell no. I agree that he'll be mid tier at best. He has too much trouble against:
Snake
MK
falco
Toon Link
wolf
IC
ROB
pika
diddy

to be high/top tier, or even top of mid

However as I can say from off the top of my head that he is a decent choice against:
Mario
Luigi
Peach
Wario
DK
Kirby
DDD
Ganon
Falcon
Sonic
and evenish/SLIGHTLY disadvantaged against everyone else...as well as a suprisingly good matchup against olimar, marth and fox (high tier possibilities), he should probably be in mid mid-tier.
 

Furbs

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Dec 23, 2007
Messages
442
Location
Bidoof
Lucas is top tier for many reasons. He has an awesome aerial game, an awesome ground game, three projectiles (2 of which are very good), disjointed hitboxes, a way to absorb projectiles, good edgeguarding, tether recovery, & great range (especially u-smash). Recovery is gimpable but not terrible.

Yoshi is one of those characters that I'm not too knowledgable about. The reason I put him in bottom tier is because he really doesn't have any standout good qualities. His ground game is about average, his aerial game is decent, his range is about average, he has an okay projectile, & his recovery is the most predictable in the game. If you can give me some more information on Yoshi, I could move him up but so far I don't see any reason for him to be any higher than low tier.
Yoshi is honestly a great candidate for mid.

His air game isn't decent its amazing! he has nearly no landing lag on all of his attacks, Uair is an incredibly good K.O. move for yoshi and is disjointed, nair is awesome for edge guarding and only gets better when used with his double jump, Bair has incredible range, is disjointed, combos, and can go towards a f-tilt/jab combo with little to no lag, and fair is a spike and even if you dont spike has a lot of knockback so you can KO off the side (not from stage from air of course :D). the only move i don't find myself using in the air is his Dair, its not a bad attack.....its just very situational, and tricky, but it does around 20-40 damage, and can be linked to a d-smash/tilt.

I do agree though that his ground game isn't fantastic, it is average. not saying it's bad, his smashes are fast, and all but they don't have a lot of power to them :/, they can kill, its just a pain sometimes because they usually KO at 130-160. his tilts are great though, disjointed, plenty of range, and can lead to other attacks. he actually does have a lot of options for approaching, and his eggroll is actually a good move. also his eggs are good for edgeguarding, and pressuring

His grabs are decent, but you'll want to use pivot grabs more than regular grabs because of startup lag. I've found that yoshi can actually "chain grab" a few characters (metaknight and sonic to name a few) but it's not that effective because he can't chain grab across the stage like a certain pair of birds can >.>, and its not too hard to get out of.

the major thing that kills me when i play as him is his defensive game. he has a very durable shield that doesn't shrink, but at the same time he cant really punish out of his shield. which really does hold him back.

also as for predictable recovery, up-b doesn't take your second jump so you can use it to stall, and the use the super armor frames on his second jump. plus if your opponent is above you as you recover you can still double jump-air dodge and gain full distance.
 

Corner-Trap

Smash Ace
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
Messages
535
Location
Fayetteville, NC
actually, G&W is my favorite character, followed by wario, kirby, IC, fox, luigi, ROB and pikachu. I just main bowser.

I have no illuions on how good/bad bowser is. I'm merely prenting facts. If I had frame data I'd use it, but as it is just trust that my approach to both brawl and debates is based on amassing knowledge. Your "facts" were for the most part wrong, and presented in an obviously biased way.

As to your question, the answer is hell no. I agree that he'll be mid tier at best. He has too much trouble against:
Snake
MK
falco
Toon Link
wolf
IC
ROB
pika
diddy

to be high/top tier, or even top of mid

However as I can say from off the top of my head that he is a decent choice against:
Mario
Luigi
Peach
Wario
DK
Kirby
DDD
Ganon
Falcon
Sonic
and evenish/SLIGHTLY disadvantaged against everyone else...as well as a suprisingly good matchup against olimar, marth and fox (high tier possibilities), he should probably be in mid mid-tier.
I think Luigi, DK, Kirby, and DDD all have slight advantages against Bowser, possibly a 6/4. But you're really going to have to explain on how Bowser has any kind of advantage versus Olimar, Marth, and Fox. I could see him possibly going even against Fox, but Marth and Olimar have the definite advantage here.
 

St. Viers

Smash Champion
Joined
May 15, 2006
Messages
2,409
Location
Boston MA
I'd say that yoshi's lack of a defensive game is his biggest problem. One of my friends, who seems to have natural talent for the game (plays ROB, DK, and various others) has picked him up for the taunts (where's my tail...where... there it is does well with him, when he can be on the offenstive, due to the previously mentioned reasons. However, whenever the flow of the fight shifts, he gets screwed, because he's really vunerable in the shield

@ corner trap:
Not advantage, just a surprisingly good matchup. Like the mew2 having a few tricks on fox, even though the matchup was heavily in fox's favor. This would be the tricks you accused him of having

vs Olimar:
Bowser is good at getting people off the edge, even if not so good keeping them there. because of Olimar's bad recovery bowser can mess up Olimar quickly sometimes. Also, Bowser eats pikmin for breakfast. Still definitely olimar's favor though.

vs Marth:
Again, just does suprisingly well, thanks to his ground game being better than marth's. Also, he can gimp marth's using his B downwards over the ledge.

vs Fox: he just goes even, thanks to lasers not being as bad as most projectiles, plus outranges him. Have to watch out for his speed, but as fox's throws got nerfed, it isn't so bad.

Honestly, when I said suprising, I meant not as bad as one would think, when looking at his other similar matchups. Not that booser had advantage


Anywho, re: DDD, luigi, and kirby, DK:

DK could be 6/4, because of his grotesquely better air game, but bowser does well against him, ime (in my experience)

DDD is too slow, though his spam game makes it interesting, I'd still say even

Luigi: I don't have much experience, would be interested in your reasoning here.

Nice being able to talk to people intelligently!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom