On the way back from Ann Arbor, we had a discussion on how many characters in Brawl have at some point been considered top tier:Lol I remembered back then people use to say Olimar is top tier material.
Mario: Before release.
Luigi: Immediately after Japanese release.
Bowser: Before release.
Diddy: Immediately after Japanese release.
Wario: Current US Tourney Results.
Toon Link: Immediately after US release.
Zamus: Immediately after Japanese release.
ICs: Immediately after chain grab discovery.
ROB: Current SBR Tier List.
Meta Knight: Current SBR Tier List.
DeDeDe: Current SBR Tier List.
Olimar: Immediately after US release.
Fox: Some previous Japanese rankings.
Falco: Current SBR Tier List.
Wolf: Immediately after Japanese release.
Marth: Immediately after US release.
G&W: Current SBR Tier List.
Snake: Current SBR Tier List.
If you are interested, go look at Yuna's trainwreck of a thread discussing balance in Brawl; at the beginning, everyone is yelling about how broken Marth, Olimar, and Toon Link are. Today, Marth is merely high tier and the others are mid-tier... of course, that means the complainers will just move to saying Meta Knight and Snake are broken. It'll be the same thing all over again though; heck, Snake is already on the way down. It's hilarious really, just like how Shiek was "unbeatable" in Melee, or how at first people though Link's Up-b made him broken... lulz.
Got any suggestions Thinkaman other than G&W?





FOREVER.
Also, Yoshi counters Meta Knight.