I never got why some Pokemon fans hate it so much when a starter Pokemon evolves to stand on two legs or become somewhat anthropomorphic.
Personally I never particularly mind anthro evos like Incineroar and Meowscarada. Is it just bad memories from the tides of Fire/Fighting starters? Plus it feels like certain anthro starters are given more of a pass than others. Look at Greninja for example. He's pretty anthropomorphic and one of the most popular starters out there. The reverse is true too. Meganium is mostly non-anthro and is simply an awesome dinosaur, but the Pokemon fandom often makes fun of it. (Which, true, might be due to how difficult to use it is in Johto, but I feel like even outside of Johto I feel like not many people really give it a fair shot.)
And as someone who's drawn her fair share of Fakemon, I've never been bothered about what the Pokemon fandom would like or dislike to see in my starters. Alcohowl is still one of my favorite designs I've ever done, but I feel like the fandom would HATE it
This also goes for Polteargeiz, who I'm also overall very proud of, but it breaks a lot of pre-established 'rules' for starter design, and thus would be similarly contentious.
Nonetheless, I'm happy with both of these designs, but I dunno if the Poke-fandom would be quite as accepting.
I dunno, what do y'all think?