Why Would They

[Ryan Colby]

Why would they kick out a character from melee for Brawl. Why not keep all of them and make make new characters. If shiek gannandorf luigi capt falcon jigglypuff are out that would be really stupid and all the others that arn't confirmed yet. Just because there not confirmed doesn't mean there not going to be in it. And if you get rid of young Link and pichu game and wach and the others not so great then that just dumb. How could you kick off a character from number 1 or/and 2 and not put them in nuber 3 .Thats all I have to say.

Sorry about spelling im in a hurry right now.

 

[Bassoonist]

To make space for other characters that are actually original.

I think it's generally agreed around here that at least these two should be gone: Dr. Mario and Pichu.

 

[Kiki52]

I agree, I think Dr. Mario and Pichu are gonna have to go. But I can see how many have support for Ness, Roy, Mewtwo, Jigglypuff, and Falco to come back. It's all way too likely that Capt Falcon will come back anyway.

 

[FireJumpPunch]

I don't think many of the characters you mentioned will be cut from Brawl. As Bassoonist said, Dr. Mario and Pichu have the highest chances of being left out simply because they are unoriginal clones of other characters.

 

[Machete]

Only Roy, Dr. Mario, Ness and Pichu should be axed.

Mewtwo, Sheik, Mr. Game & Watch, Luigi, Jigglypuff, Marth and Captain Falcon have original movesets, so they should be in.

Ganondorf, Falco and Young Link (WW) deserve new movesets.

If we get 60 characters, then Ness, Pichu, Dr. Mario and Roy should return. But we'll get 45 at the most, if we're lucky. We need more unique and deserving characters.

 

[Superninjabreadman]

To make space for other characters that are actually original.

I think it's generally agreed around here that at least these two should be gone: Dr. Mario and Pichu.

and all the other clones need new movesets. Instead of roy, we should get Eliwood, hes just like roy, but with a bigger frame, and then we dont have all our FE characters look like teenagers, with blue hair, and a sword.

 

[Go Pit65]

Ness,Dr Mario Pichu andYoung Link have to go there all clones of others and Ness is to much like Lucas who every1 likes better. Game and watch has a small chance the rest should be in(Expect captain Falcon i hate him so much.

 

[shellblade]

jigglypuff will be in, game and watch is in due to the icon theory, falcon is the most wanted veteran, ganondorf will be remade, the same should happen for falco, and goodbye to everyone else. its sad to see roy go

 

[Go Pit65]

Marth should stya i mean nothing can take his place(Except pit)

 

[Deleted member]

Dr. Mario and Pichu are definitely out. Roy is mehish. Marth has some support but I'd like to see Black Mage and Micaiah replace him and Roy. Falco and Ganon should come back with more original movesets. Ness has a really low chance of coming back. Young Link might be back with the Wind Waker Link looks and moveset. G&W is a most wonted veteran like Mewtwo and Capt. Falcon. Luigi, Capt. Falcon, Mewtwo and Jiggernaut will be back ****it! >O

 

[y3nia659]

I think Roy, Dr. Mario, Pichu, Young Link, and Ness are completely left out...others are at risk (unconfirmed) for now.

 

[Cinder]

And, what is the point of this thread? We all know Pichu, Doc, and Roy are as good as axed, and Ness and YLink can be debated...but come on, it's not that stupid to get rid of something as worthless as Pichu...I'd be disappointed if they kept such worthless clones...especially when they can be replaced by much better characters (i.e. Geno for Doc, Lucario for Pichu, idk-Michiah for Roy)...the characters that are getting axed deserve it...

And btw, there is no excuse for bad spelling...

 

[Dgro]

In a hurry to look like a rambling idiot?

If so, mission accomplished :D

 

[SmashFi3nd]

Dr. Mario and pichu do definitely have to go. Young link could get a new moveset, but i'd rather a new unique character take his place. Falco, ganondorf, and mewtwo should get new movesets and the marth moveset should come back. Marth doesnt necessarily have to come back, but tht moveset was unique and it is good enough to come back in my opinion. Mewtwo should also get a new moveset, cuz it was just "ugh"

 

[antimatter]

i heard that some non clones are going to be cut. the non clones who haven't been confirmed are falcon, game and watch, ness, marth, shiek, jiggs, and mewtwo.

 

[dantemasta]

Because no one wants to play the same game twice. If all they do is add like 10 characters, and make some clones, then what was the point?

 

[smashbro29]

characters that gotta go: pichu doc roy ness has been deconfirmed and y. link should be changed to WW link that is all

 

[susu_atari]

I imagine the only characters that won't make it back as playable are going to be Pichu, Dr. Mario, Roy and Ness.

Ness has already been replaced, and the other 3 were clones, and I don't think they deserve new movesets thinking up for them. I'd rather just 3 new characters.

Young Link and Ganondorf will be back with new movesets (WW and TP style). Along with Link and Zelda, they're the most important characters. No way Zelda's going to get less than 4 reps.

Falco and Marth are maybes. Falco would new re-jigging, Marth is fine how he is, similar to Ike, but different enough not to be a clone.

Mewtwo may be replaced, like Ness.

Luigi, Mr. Game & Watch and Captain Falcon WILL return.

I think that's everybody covered.



oh... er.. Shiek... whatever.. probably still there... maybe slightly different to use, though.

 

[Zycor]

I didn't know so many of you guys all worked for Nintendo, none of this stuff is set in stone... We wont know who is in or who is out for 21 days so quit using myths as fact.

 

[Enigma14]

To make space for other characters that are actually original.

I think it's generally agreed around here that at least these two should be gone: Dr. Mario and Pichu.

I like the doc. YLink and Pichu need to go, doc for alt.

 

[vesperview]

I like the doc. YLink and Pichu need to go, doc for alt.

Young Link is one of the characters with the most chance of returning.

 

[susu_atari]

I like the doc. YLink and Pichu need to go, doc for alt.

Young Link doesn't need to go. That's crazy talk. Wind Waker and Phantom Hourglass are BOTH more popular in Japan than Twilight Princess. Wind Waker Link is one of the more popular characters on the character poll!

I agree that Dr. Mario would be good with a new moveset, but I don't see it happening.

 

[Ithilgore]

I think all the clones except for Ganondorf and possibly Falco will be cut, with Ganondorf and Falco getting new movesets. I don't count Luigi as a clone, and expect him back. Young Link has a chance to come back as WW Link, with a new moveset. This seems to be the general opinion on the issue with the clones.