Yoshi's Island shouldn't be neutral

[_Kamikaze]

First off, there's a tilting platform of course, and not only that but those little platform things can sprout up out of mother****ing nowhere and save someones life just because they're lucky.

 

[UltiMario]

Tilting platform is a problem..... How?

Not only does the platform save someone's life, it can ruin PK Thunder Recoveries, and make a good edgeguarding platform. The Ghost causes little damage and a bit of help.

Seems fine to me.

 

[_Kamikaze]

Tilting platform is a problem..... How?

Not only does the platform save someone's life, it can ruin PK Thunder Recoveries, and make a good edgeguarding platform. The Ghost causes little damage and a bit of help.

Seems fine to me.

That's the issue. You think you kill someone with a bad recovery such as ganon if you spike them, then they get lucky as hell and the platform comes up. Neutral stages should eliminate all factors of luck. The sprouting platforms are a luck factor.

 

[Zombieoficer]

Settle down. It's not game-breaking.

Even if you are up against a Ganondorf that's been saved, you should be reminded that you're against a Ganondorf, so you shouldn't worry anyhow.

 

[M.K]

Settle down. It's not game-breaking.

Even if you are up against a Ganondorf that's been saved, you should be reminded that you're against a Ganondorf, so you shouldn't worry anyhow.

What a lame excuse for an answer. I know plenty of Ganondorfs that aren't bad.

I think it is a close one between Neutral and Counterpick. It's slightly more neutral, but that platform is so dumb. Gimps my recoveries, hampers my attempts to ledgeguard....

 

[znintendotaku]

1: no swearing
2: this belongs in stage discussion
3: that stage is 99.99% germ free AND 100% nuetral
4: chillax dawg it just a game, aight?
5: im 650% white

 

[M.K]

1: no swearing
2: this belongs in stage discussion
3: that stage is 99.99% germ free AND 100% nuetral
4: chillax dawg it just a game, aight?
5: im 650% white

1. That's not a rule.
2. Agreed.
3. Eh, more like 80 good/20 bad
4. NUH-UH!!!
5. I call Shenanigans!

 

[Sosuke]

Theres no problem with this stage.

 

[gallax]

this stage talk is in the wrong section. but while its here im gonna say its nuetral and it should be. there is nothing here that would make it a counterpick.

 

[MarKO X]

this is sooooooo gonna get locked.

 

[znintendotaku]

this is sooooooo gonna get locked.

dammit thats what i forgot to do...

inB4lock

 

[DAGanmanert]

Before its locked Ill just agree and say its pretty much neutral...tho it can be annoying

 

[fredymartinez1]

what was the point of this topic again....

 

[smashbot226]

what was the point of this topic again....

PANCAKES.

I like the Canadian ones with fresh maple syrup.

 

[fredymartinez1]

ah I remember now!
Yea I like pancakes... Who doesn't!

 

[smashbot226]

Yes, they are quite good.

However, I dislike Aunt Jemima's syrup with them.

I also enjoy eating Frosted Flakes and a banana on the side. Sometimes I put chocolate chips in my pancakes for added flavor.

It's a good thing.

 

[Fluke]

Is the ghost platform random? I thought it had a set time, alternating between the sides.

I must have played batttlefield/fd/smashville too much. or never payed attention.

 

[fredymartinez1]

fluke ur getting off topic.....

 

[Talazala]

fluke ur getting off topic.....

Get a load of Smashbot.

And no. Yoshi's island is totally fine. HAVEN'T YOU EVER HEARD OF RANDALL??

 

[Problem2]

Is the ghost platform random? I thought it had a set time, alternating between the sides.

I must have played batttlefield/fd/smashville too much. or never payed attention.

That's what I thought. The elements of Yoshi's island meager effects aren't even random, so it's perfectly fair (or close enough). Besides, we have little neutral stages as it is.

 

[MarKO X]

pancakes are good, very good. Top em off with either applefillin, blueberryfillin, or whipcream, and then add syrup... awesomeness.

 

[fredymartinez1]

oh so
were getting back on topic now....

 

[fredymartinez1]

pancakes are good, very good. Top em off with either applefillin, blueberryfillin, or whipcream, and then add syrup... awesomeness.

I get blinded after every meal from pure awesomeness!

 

[Dav657]

yoshi's story from melee( the good one) was perfectly legal and i think it was a neutral. And i think this level should be the new fd.

 

[NinjaFoxX]

Yes, they are quite good.

However, I dislike Aunt Jemima's syrup with them.
.

what?thats like the best kind,espcially with blueberry pancakes

and besides,Waffles>Pancakes and yoshis island is neutral

 

[theONEjanitor]

there's no stage on any game thats 100% neutral.
yoshi's is as good as any of the other neutrals.

 

[Sosuke]

I'm honestly surprised this thread isn't closed by now.

 

[smashbot226]

there's no stage on any game thats 100% neutral.

Ever notice how Final Destination is as flat and even as a pancake?

Let's discuss this serious matter by asking ourselves:

1) Will this give way to possible series representation for Pancakes?

2) Has Sakurai taken an interest in forming a friendship with BisQuix?

3) Is it possible to see Pancake as a new character in the next possible Smash Bros. game?

 

[Mic_128]

I'm honestly surprised this thread isn't closed by now.

you know, if people would STOP posting 'why isnt this closed" or "this will be closed" it'd be left alone, fall under the other topics and we wouldn't need closing. It's sad that us mods have lives to live, since you guys need 24/7 babysitting, hmm?

aaaaanyway, the stage is fine.

Slight tilt? Oh no. So dangerous.

Chance to land on the ghost? Yoshi's Story Melee anyone?

Next time, peae post in the stage room.