But that's the thing, EVERYBODY thinks that way. Yes, even you. If you made your own match-up chart would you have Ness >> Zelda because of that thread where the poster claimed that it was basically his easiest match-up? For all intents and purposes, this chart is a visual indication of what I've been lead to believe about the match-ups. Like tiers and other such stuff, everybody has their own opinion.
For plenty of match-ups I've been pursuaded by others, but just the same there are plenty more where I am simply not convinced.
Problem is, for this type of chart, it SHOULDN'T be your personal opinion, it should be based on the consensus of the community (really, the best sources are the character match-up boards).
As of right now, you are maintaining THE Brawl Character match-up chart, a brawl match-up chart, which means that you have to accept the fact that you simply don't have as much experience as the community as a whole, and you'd be better to refer to more efficient sources instead of trusting your judgment.
It is a guide after all, in order to help the community it has to be as accurate as possible, and 1 person's opinions, knowledge and experience < the entire community's opinions, knowledge, and experience.
I personally agree that it's Peach>Olimar, but I think Peach>>Olimar is a bit much. Most disagree with me though, so I can understand if you and Ivan want it to be that way. I've got no problem with it. The Olimar boards currently have the matchup as 65:35 Peach.
The reasons I think Peach>Olimar and not Peach>>Olimar is just b/c of Olimar's character traits. He's got SO much freakin range that even with all of Peach's approaches and ways to get off the pikmin, it can trouble Peach. This is IMO from personal experience. I'll admit it's hard, but there's ways around Peach's floating, her priority, and her gimping.
When I say range, I'm mostly talking about the disjointedness on his grab, fsmash, upsmash, and pikmin throw. Those alone are enough to keep most characters from having an advantage over him regardless of every other advantage they have over Olimar.
EVERYONE has priority over Olimar's pikmin attacks. They don't even have priority. Sonic has priority on his attacks. This is something we have to deal with every match. They way we get around these are his speed, quickness, the speed on his attacks, his mobility, WAC (his whistle SA), the range on his attacks, disjointedness, and his small size. Peach is no different from any other character, except that she can float, which can pose a problem. (and this is why people say Peach>Olimar) If she didn't have the float, it wouldn't be any different from any other matchup.
I'd rather not discuss the specifics why Peach>Olimar. I have some stuff that needs to get done tonight. Maybe later. I'll answer any other questions you have tomorrow.
Really, it's not that I want it to be, I just think it does more service to people to know precisely how things are. It seems every match-up discussion that has involved ganondorf, I've argued he is at a disadvantage, in spite of the fact that he's my secondary, why? Because I have experience with him, I know what issues he has, and if he gets an advantageous match-up that isn't actually advantagious, then ganondorf players will be at a disadvantage, thinking they've got an easy fight when they haven't. That's the tact I take with every match-up, only hurts people to be inaccurate.
Yeah, I know the grab, problem is, peach can pretty much stay aerial whenever she is in range of it. Things that can reach in the air, she can easily outprioritize, especially her because of her bair and dair. The fact that she can maintain this to approach...
Sure, the float is only one advantage, but for this particular match-up it's amazing advantage which just shuts down just about everything Olimar can do, in combination with her aerials. The overb is a nice touch as well, because it activates on the pikaman, and the bair to jab coming out before sheildgrab just seals the deal.
Over match-ups, speed mobility, vB, and disjointedness get around the priority issue. Unfortunately, not this one.
Having played this match-up as an utterly newb peach (not a secondary, just picked her up a few times to play out this match-up) against some very experienced Olimars, I just found that Peach just controls the match too reliably if she abuses her strengths.
Debate it when you want though, I have no objection to waiting on your response.