Something it didn’t seem like you considered in your argument was human error.(for a good reason too. It's a very touchy subject, I've learned...) But if we completely disregard THAT aspect of game play and talk specifically about perfect players, then this thread and any other thread is pointless, as no-one would ever hit anyone with any move and no-one would die...so on and so forth. You get the point. But, seriously, there’s a degree of human error we have to consider when playing brawl... Shieldgrabbing your opponent, for instance requires your opponent to attack you and mess-up in distancing themselves after the attack. It’s a pretty common technique used, and everybody (even the best) falls prey to it. Grabbing in general can be completely avoided for an entire match though unlike jabs, and aerials. (If not, IC’s cg should and will be banned)