PrettyIvyPearls22
Smash Ace
This guy is anything but Optimistic even when it comes to Geno, it doesn't help that he bashes and singles out DQ because of a SINGLE COMPOSER, and it's honestly not fair. His thoughts are just too clouded. Look, if you're going to come in here look at both pros and cons for Geno and not just the positives! Yes, he is likely as a canididate; but don't bash other Square who have just as much of a right to be in Smash just as much as Geno does. They are all popular choices, all of them have great reasons to be in Smash, but they also have their problems.
Dragon Quest-I know that DQ is a lincensing hell with the music just like Final Fantasy, but he keeps bringing up a single composer to bash the franchise in general. It has a whole country behind it, and it's one of Square's biggest franchises, it would make sense to put someone from there, but it lacks popularity with any other region. Not only that but DQ also has the problem of who do you go to for it. Slime, Erdrick, or do you go to the most recent hero that most people probably won't know. I think that's another thing for Dragon Quest.
Kingdom Hearts-With Sora, he's probably their next big character after Cloud and Sephiroth that's even on the list. Kingdom Hearts is one of Square bigger franchises out there next to Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest. People write him off because, of "muh Disney" I and some other people have already stated Sora's case, and why it wouldn't be that difficult as many would think. I don't think Disney would really care that much, just as long as it benefits them somehow.
Chrono Trigger-Chrono is in a similar situation as Geno, but not by much; I don't even think there's many legalties with Chrono (then again I just learned about the DQ thing, with the music, so Chrono could also have some trouble that I don't know about, but he would appeal to the old school crowd and would put the "hey, Goku is in Smash kinda" motif.
Sephiroth is another character that don't need much of an introduction. If he were to get in he would be our first third party who's a villain (and honestly, Smash is still kinda lacking with them) Sephiroth is one of the most iconic video game villains out there, (along with Bowser, Ganondorf, Eggman) but the problem with Seph probably is FFVII in particular is already represented in the game by it's most popular and known character (Cloud represents not only FFVII, but just Final Fantasy in general). Sephiroth is practically not needed, and then you have the whole sword issue with Sephiroth, that could potentially hinder his moveset potential.
This is how you debate, not just put positives only and BUT also the negatives. If you just look at the positives only, people will think your just propping characters. You have to look at their whole situation, not just the positives. Again, this thread was to discuss all characters from the list and see who's likely, not to tear any character down. We all have our favorites, and we all wish they could get in, but we also know that some characters just seem more likely than others, and we have to look at all of it and see what these guys could bring to the table.
Dragon Quest-I know that DQ is a lincensing hell with the music just like Final Fantasy, but he keeps bringing up a single composer to bash the franchise in general. It has a whole country behind it, and it's one of Square's biggest franchises, it would make sense to put someone from there, but it lacks popularity with any other region. Not only that but DQ also has the problem of who do you go to for it. Slime, Erdrick, or do you go to the most recent hero that most people probably won't know. I think that's another thing for Dragon Quest.
Kingdom Hearts-With Sora, he's probably their next big character after Cloud and Sephiroth that's even on the list. Kingdom Hearts is one of Square bigger franchises out there next to Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest. People write him off because, of "muh Disney" I and some other people have already stated Sora's case, and why it wouldn't be that difficult as many would think. I don't think Disney would really care that much, just as long as it benefits them somehow.
Chrono Trigger-Chrono is in a similar situation as Geno, but not by much; I don't even think there's many legalties with Chrono (then again I just learned about the DQ thing, with the music, so Chrono could also have some trouble that I don't know about, but he would appeal to the old school crowd and would put the "hey, Goku is in Smash kinda" motif.
Sephiroth is another character that don't need much of an introduction. If he were to get in he would be our first third party who's a villain (and honestly, Smash is still kinda lacking with them) Sephiroth is one of the most iconic video game villains out there, (along with Bowser, Ganondorf, Eggman) but the problem with Seph probably is FFVII in particular is already represented in the game by it's most popular and known character (Cloud represents not only FFVII, but just Final Fantasy in general). Sephiroth is practically not needed, and then you have the whole sword issue with Sephiroth, that could potentially hinder his moveset potential.
This is how you debate, not just put positives only and BUT also the negatives. If you just look at the positives only, people will think your just propping characters. You have to look at their whole situation, not just the positives. Again, this thread was to discuss all characters from the list and see who's likely, not to tear any character down. We all have our favorites, and we all wish they could get in, but we also know that some characters just seem more likely than others, and we have to look at all of it and see what these guys could bring to the table.
Last edited: