• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Where's my MOTHER?

espio87

Smash Ace
Joined
Jan 22, 2006
Messages
654
Location
Bahía Blanca, Argentina
I know. Although, according to the decryption, some music was cut. Maybe it was Catherine Warwick's Pollyanna and Bein' Friends, the St. Peter's Cathedrial Choir's Eight Melodies, and the Giygas Theme.
rest assured, Polyanna, Bein' Friends and the Eight Melodies (these last two in their Mother 1 arrangement from melee)made it.:)
I just finished Mother 3 a few moments ago. man, the ending is so sad.
I never expected Claus to kill himself:(. I'm not a person that cries easily, but I was close to do it.
kinda off-topic, but it seems that the Smash franchise is the only thing that can introduce Japan-only franchises to the rest of the world (yes, I'm talking about you Fire Emblem). I just wished nintendo would've put more of those japan-only characters:(.
EDIT:btw, *SSE Spoilers*
in the SSE, when we see Lucas's part of the story he's seen in a deserted and ruined town. I first thought it was the ruins of New Pork City, but I considered it could be his hometown. does it recall any place in Mother 3 to you?
 

Big-Cat

Challenge accepted.
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
16,176
Location
Lousiana
NNID
KumaOso
3DS FC
1590-4853-0104
People will certainly agree that Ness has no personality, but does Link suck for his lack of personality?

No?

****ing right.

Oh, and why in the world would we get rid of PK Thunder?

Ideal moveset =

Lucas:
B: PK Freeze
Smash B: PK Fire
Up B: PK Thunder
Down B: PK Earth
Final Smash: PK Starstorm

Ness:
B: PK Flash
Smash B: PK Brainshock
Up B: PK Teleport
Down B: PK Shield
Final Smash: PK Rockin'

Simple. Lucas is primarily offensive, Ness is primarily defensive. Give Ness some extra speed and jump, Lucas the extra offense.
Why get rid of Lucas' PK LOVE? Are you trying to be faithful to the original source or what?
 
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
1,538
"Get rid of"? If Lucas is set up with Freeze, Fire, Thunder, and Earth, Love would be terribly inconsistent. To give them both what amounts to the same move would be silly and go against the idea of "unique-ifying" the two characters, and Starstorm is too important of a move to flat-out ignore.
 

Big-Cat

Challenge accepted.
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
16,176
Location
Lousiana
NNID
KumaOso
3DS FC
1590-4853-0104
"Get rid of"? If Lucas is set up with Freeze, Fire, Thunder, and Earth, Love would be terribly inconsistent. To give them both what amounts to the same move would be silly and go against the idea of "unique-ifying" the two characters, and Starstorm is too important of a move to flat-out ignore.
How the hell would Love be inconsistent? Also, it's PK Ground, not Earth.

I have no idea what the second sentence means other than that you think my moveset isn't differing the two enough. By the way, PK Love is more important than PK Starstorm. Let Poo and Kumatora use that move, not them.
 

espio87

Smash Ace
Joined
Jan 22, 2006
Messages
654
Location
Bahía Blanca, Argentina
How the hell would Love be inconsistent? Also, it's PK Ground, not Earth.

I have no idea what the second sentence means other than that you think my moveset isn't differing the two enough. By the way, PK Love is more important than PK Starstorm. Let Poo and Kumatora use that move, not them.
I kind of agree with you that PK Love would be better for Lucas, but I think they could make it as a B move (PK Love Alpha) and at the same time keep PK Starstorm as his Final Smash (It's just that I love his FS animation)
 

Big-Cat

Challenge accepted.
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
16,176
Location
Lousiana
NNID
KumaOso
3DS FC
1590-4853-0104
Ness has a better animation, even though it's the same. Maybe it's because I like hearing Ness going PK....
STAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARSTOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORM!
 

M.K

Level 55
Joined
Jul 10, 2007
Messages
6,033
Location
North Carolina
I must say, I've NEVER played a game from the Mother Franchise...but dear lord...."Smashing Song of Praise" is downright wonderful!
 
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
1,538
PK Love and PK Rockin' are, from what I see, the same move, or the same idea.

Letting them both have Rockin' and Love is the same as letting them both have PK Starstorm - it basically says "let's unclone them by giving them the same move!".
 

Big-Cat

Challenge accepted.
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
16,176
Location
Lousiana
NNID
KumaOso
3DS FC
1590-4853-0104
PK Love and PK Rockin' are, from what I see, the same move, or the same idea.

Letting them both have Rockin' and Love is the same as letting them both have PK Starstorm - it basically says "let's unclone them by giving them the same move!".
I wouldn't say so. If it means anything, the "shapes" for PK Love and PK Rockin' are completely different. Anyway, when you have two characters that are already similar by their nature means they're going to have similarities.
 
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
1,538
Which would justify them having the same moves, meaning they don't need a moveset.

They have enough differences that they could - and should - have different moves.
 

Big-Cat

Challenge accepted.
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
16,176
Location
Lousiana
NNID
KumaOso
3DS FC
1590-4853-0104
Which would justify them having the same moves, meaning they don't need a moveset.

They have enough differences that they could - and should - have different moves.
I don't know. Now that I think about, Luigifications of each other would probably be the best and most appropriate.
 

PrettyGoodYear

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 1, 2007
Messages
1,792
Location
Panama, Panama, Central America...
Which would justify them having the same moves, meaning they don't need a moveset.

They have enough differences that they could - and should - have different moves.
Ness and Lucas should be a bit similar, just not similar to Paula, Kumatora, or Poo.

PK Love and Rockin have different abstract representation, that could very well translate to different moves Smash wise. The other move Lucas has is PK Flash, and well, he wouldn't be able to charge it. Who knows. There's potential.
 

Masque

Keeper of the Keys
Joined
Aug 9, 2001
Messages
2,660
Location
Subcon
Needs MOAR CLAUS! But, other franchises needed more rep other than MOTHER though. Metroid, F-Zero, Donkey Kong (King K FTW!), Fire Emblem, Perhaps even Wario or Yoshi IMO.
True that, my friend.
MOTHER: Claus / Masked Man (without question)
F-Zero: Black Shadow (I guess...)
DK: King K. Rool
FE: Lyn, Micaiah, Hector, or whoever the new lord is at the time
Wario: Mona or Captain Syrup
Yoshi: Kamek

It's a little iffy, though. I still don't really know if Kamek would be appropriate, and same thing with Mona. These franchises are offshoots of one major franchise (Mario), so it's hard to say whether or not they should be getting another rep next time around.

I think the chances of at least getting those characters in is if we have someone else do the next one that's willing to be as accurate as possible to the original sources.

By the way, if that happens, this should be Lucas and Ness' movesets:

Lucas:
B: PK Love: Lucas releases PK Love from the heart and it explodes with a medium radius.

Side B: Salt Water Gun: Shoots out salt water that damages with its bad taste. Has minor knockback. It can be held down with the B button until it's all out.

Down B: PK Counter: Lucas sets up a shield around around himself. When he's hit, the shield shatters and attacks the opponent.

Up B: Bird Cage: Takes out a cage filled with birds that raise him up.

Final Smash: PK Love Ω: Like the regular PK Love but it covers the entire stage if it's done from the center of the stage.

Ness:

B: PK Paralysis: Works like how Ness' PK Flash works already in the SSB series. However, this freezes the opponent in place.

Side B: PK Flash: Shoots out a grean beam that, if it hits the opponent, leaves the opponent in a broken shield state.

Down B: PK Hypnosis: Works like Mewtwo's but better range and inflicts no damage.

Up B: PK Teleport: Disappears and then poofs out of nowhere like Shiek, Mewtwo, and Zelda.

Final Smash: PK ROCKIN'!!!!!!!!!!!: Ness makes a guitar out of PSI and then starts playing a rock version of Pollyanna. The notes then go off in random directions and Ness is invincible during this.

Grab: Instead of the Rope Snake, he uses the Shield Snatcher.
Hmm...accurate, yes. It's a shame to lose PK Thunder. Actually, it's a shame to lose most of those moves. From what I've seen, I really love Lucas' playstyle. Your moveset is very creative, though. I might change his B move since he already uses forms of PK Love in his standard attacks; Omega is still acceptable as a FS. I would love to see a cool animation along the lines of an FF Limit Break, maybe with an appearance by Hinawa's ghost. :)

People will certainly agree that Ness has no personality, but does Link suck for his lack of personality?

No?

****ing right.

Oh, and why in the world would we get rid of PK Thunder?

Ideal moveset =

Lucas:
B: PK Freeze
Smash B: PK Fire
Up B: PK Thunder
Down B: PK Earth
Final Smash: PK Starstorm

Ness:
B: PK Flash
Smash B: PK Brainshock
Up B: PK Teleport
Down B: PK Shield
Final Smash: PK Rockin'

Simple. Lucas is primarily offensive, Ness is primarily defensive. Give Ness some extra speed and jump, Lucas the extra offense.
There's a difference, though. With Link, you don't have other options. He IS the Legend of Zelda. With the MOTHER series, however, you have multiple heroes from which you might choose. There is also the fact that we're talking two different genres. With action, Link's stoic composure is an essence of his personality: the strong, silent hero. With RPGs, however, having a main character like Ness--an average kid who doesn't talk--kind of takes away from the experience because RPGs are, by nature, more personality-driven (in my opinion).

Cool to see PK Ground, though.

How the hell would Love be inconsistent? Also, it's PK Ground, not Earth.

I have no idea what the second sentence means other than that you think my moveset isn't differing the two enough. By the way, PK Love is more important than PK Starstorm. Let Poo and Kumatora use that move, not them.
It would probably go to Kumatora, only because I see her getting in before Poo.

If I had to make movesets, I'd give Lucas and Ness their own moves, and give their old set to Paula/Kumatora/Poo.
In theory, it's a great idea. The problem: when has Sakurai ever completely redone someone's moveset--not just in the Mario sense of "replace a move," but an all-out new moveset? (Plus, they would still come after Claus's inclusion, so that means MOTHER would need four reps for your idea to come through. It's good, but unlikely.)

I don't know. I think Lucas sounds better. but that's just me. although the wider arc in Ness's starstorm may seem useful in the bigger stages
Agreed. I like that he puts the emphasis on the first syllable, as opposed to Ness's second-syllable stress.

I must say, I've NEVER played a game from the Mother Franchise...but dear lord...."Smashing Song of Praise" is downright wonderful!
Ah, it's so true! Frankly, all of the M3 music that they chose is wonderful, ESPECIALLY the M3 Love Theme! It's absolutely beautiful. :bigthumbu

Which would justify them having the same moves, meaning they don't need a moveset.

They have enough differences that they could - and should - have different moves.
The problem is that Sakurai won't change them. (Plus, I just like Lucas the way he is.) It would certainly be more accurate, however.

I don't know. Now that I think about, Luigifications of each other would probably be the best and most appropriate.
So changes made to both of them, making them even further apart than Mario and Luigi? Revolutionary. ;)
 
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
1,538
PK Love is to PK Rockin' as Fire Arrows are to Arrows.

Each character should be unique as possible. There isn't anything forcing them to use the same move, so why must they use the same move?

At what point is PK Starstorm not important enough to the point where instead of this unique move, we get a Luigified move?
 

PrettyGoodYear

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 1, 2007
Messages
1,792
Location
Panama, Panama, Central America...
PK Love is to PK Rockin' as Fire Arrows are to Arrows.

Each character should be unique as possible. There isn't anything forcing them to use the same move, so why must they use the same move?

At what point is PK Starstorm not important enough to the point where instead of this unique move, we get a Luigified move?
How 'bout the fact that they both have the same move? :ohwell:

PK Love and Rockin can be done differently.

EDIT: And Sakurai might not make the next Smash game. Who knows, it could be Miyamoto, or someone else. Then we might have a chance for movesets to switch, particularly Ganondorf's.
 
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
1,538
So? Lots of people have similar moves. If we're going to go that far, why even revise them?

B: PK Freeze
Smash B: PK Fire
Up B: PK Thunder
Down B: PK Shield
Final Smash: PK Starstorm

B: PK Flash
Smash B: PK Fire
up B: PK Thunder
Down B: PK Shield
Final Smash: PK Starstorm

That argument can be used against any new move. Why bother adding any new move, if they're so similar?

There hasn't been any problem with the lack of PK Rockin'/Love, so how do people take issue with the lack of either or?
 

Big-Cat

Challenge accepted.
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
16,176
Location
Lousiana
NNID
KumaOso
3DS FC
1590-4853-0104
How 'bout the fact that they both have the same move? :ohwell:

PK Love and Rockin can be done differently.

EDIT: And Sakurai might not make the next Smash game. Who knows, it could be Miyamoto, or someone else. Then we might have a chance for movesets to switch, particularly Ganondorf's.
Hopefully, the person who does it is willing to give reps to the minority series.

By the way, what I have in mind for Ness and Lucas is really just a change in special and final smash moves. Maybe a change in some A moves if necessary.
 

PrettyGoodYear

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 1, 2007
Messages
1,792
Location
Panama, Panama, Central America...
So? Lots of people have similar moves. If we're going to go that far, why even revise them?

B: PK Freeze
Smash B: PK Fire
Up B: PK Thunder
Down B: PK Shield
Final Smash: PK Starstorm

B: PK Flash
Smash B: PK Fire
up B: PK Thunder
Down B: PK Shield
Final Smash: PK Starstorm

That argument can be used against any new move. Why bother adding any new move, if they're so similar?

There hasn't been any problem with the lack of PK Rockin'/Love, so how do people take issue with the lack of either or?
I'll do this step by step. Since you can't obviously see where I'm coming from.

1. Ness being added into Smash Bros. 64 = Good
2. Ness taking his moves from Paula = Bad
3. Ness getting Flash in Melee = Good
4. Ness still robbing Paula = Bad
5. Paula can't even get in as a clone = Super bad
6. Lucas getting in Brawl = Good
7. Lucas getting Kumatora's moves = bad.
8. Ness getting in Brawl = Good
9. Lucas and Ness getting their Final Smash from Kumatora/Poo = Bad
10. All of the above + the fact Ness and Lucas both have plenty to draw from = Sucks for Mother fans

Get it? Ness (and Lucas) getting new moves to be faithful to the franchise is all I've wanted since SSB. I mean, I'm content. Sakurai could've of just said "Screw Mother!!" And I wouldn't get anything, but still... all these years I've been using PK Fire and PK Thunder and it feels... wrong. :dizzy: and it looks like I have another 5-7 years ahead of it again... times double. It's not something that bothers me to the point of not using them (like Ganondorf) but it still bothers me.

It's like Mario suddenly used Bowser's Fire Breath :ohwell:
 

AdmantNESS

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 9, 2007
Messages
553
Location
TX
To everyone saying Ness has no personality: After playing the game and reading much about it, it just wouldn't be accurate to describe Ness in the same way Link or Crono is. While Ness never speaks, insight is gained while listening to what others say about him, especially
himself
near the end of the game.

Paying attention to the game's dialogue I have gained some insight on him, especially the dialogue in
Lumine Hall, the breaks, and especiallyMagicant
. I mean, I know he doesn't compare to Lucas in the character department, but I just don't like it when people say Ness has no personality or development whatsoever. I guess you can call it subtle indirect character development(though its very little compared to fully/partially developed RPG heroes). Here are some dialogue sniplets and my impressions on them. Earthbound dialogue spoilers:

"You may have cursed this never ending journey..."(He probably never wanted to leave home in the first place or just hated how difficult the journey was)
"I'm Ness... It's been a long road getting here... Soon, I'll be... Soon, I'll be... Soon, I'll be... What will happen to us? W...what's happening? My thoughts are being written out on the wall... or are they?"(Seems worried or scared, doesn't seem personalityless to me)
"The Apple of Enlightenment has foretold that Giygas' attempt will fail. It is because of the existence of a boy named Ness. ...That's me! Listen. Free your mind and KNOW what you must do! "We must be quick!" (Ness really heard his own voice)(Well, he is determined at this point).

There is more, but you all get the idea.

And as for those movesets, I get the impression that Sakurai is reluctant (Or just plain doesn't want) to animate PK Rockin or PK Love in the way its shown in their games as full blown waves of attack. We got Lucas showing hexagons in a few of his standard atks, but that's all we get in terms of that.

And I know Ness is mainly a high-off physical attacker with Assist/Defensive PSI and only 2 offensive PSI. And I assume its the same or similar for Lucas? I can only assume that Sakurai wants Ness and Lucas to use Offensive PSI(except Love/Rockin) though they don't have those moves(Freeze/Starstorm/Fire/Thunder/Magnet) in their games alongside being physical attackers in Smash. Of course, this means no Paula or Kumatora sadly.
 
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
1,538
...So, basically, you'd rather have Sakurai ignore most of EarthBound's most memorable moves when giving Ness a moveset?

B: PK Flash
Smash B: PK Brainshock
Up B: PK Teleport
Down B: PSI Shield
Final Smash: PK Rockin'

That'd be awesome. Unless you factor in the fact that it's not.
 

Kiki52

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Dec 9, 2007
Messages
418
While I do agree that Ness and Lucas should have gotten their own moveset based on things other than Paula's and Kumatora's moves, I think many people might not like those changes. They'd say "What the heck happened to Ness and Lucas?". Although personally I would support it, especially if that means Ness gets PK Rockin and Lucas gets PK Love.
Having Paula and Kumatora and/or Claus as PCs would be much better. Claus has high level lightning moves and freeze I think, and his light sword. He could like a high damage but short ranged character (except the lightning and freeze), and I bet lots of casuals would use him because of his energy-based sword.

My cousin who didn't like MOTHER as much after seeing Earthbound just now, really likes it. But I do think most Fire Emblem, Metriod, DK fans would be so angry if MOTHER got 5 PC reps, even if they did include the alt character idea. Some would argue they should include at least 6 Fire Emblem reps afterwards.

Also, if Sakurai isn't the next one hopefully this new person who managers SSB4 would be more lenient and take the time to add more than 35 characters, including at least Claus and Paula. Kumatora looks interesting but I just haven't had the chance to develop more emotional ties with that character because I never played MOTHER 3, but I bet she probably is more developed character-wise than Paula or any Mother 2 character for that matter. Claus, I can understand because he kills himself, and it seems like a reinactment of Darth Vader if you ask me.

Ness though, even though he never talks I think the point of Ness more is that he is supposed to represent you. You know how Gordon Freedman from Half-Life never talked? Or how the Saints Row guy you are never talked either? It's because when character developers do that, they intent for you to try to step into Ness' shoes and you become him. It's not any better or worse than having roleplaying a different character, it's just a different way of doing it. I do agree Ness' shouldn't be hated because he isn't as developed as Lucas is personality wise, especially considering Link is almost the same in that way. The same can be said of the Pokemon Trainer or Chrono as someone here said. I personally am glad Ness made it.
 

Rakath

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 20, 2007
Messages
643
Personally, I'd of perferred either Ness + Paula or Lucas + Kumatora as the reps. Not because I like Mother 3 or Mother 2 higher than the other, but to add a female rep and to have a good place to put the old Special moveset for one of them...

I don't care which pair is used, just so long as its a pair from the same series, makes it easier and all...
 

Big-Cat

Challenge accepted.
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
16,176
Location
Lousiana
NNID
KumaOso
3DS FC
1590-4853-0104
Personally, I'd of perferred either Ness + Paula or Lucas + Kumatora as the reps. Not because I like Mother 3 or Mother 2 higher than the other, but to add a female rep and to have a good place to put the old Special moveset for one of them...

I don't care which pair is used, just so long as its a pair from the same series, makes it easier and all...
To be honest, I think most people would prefer just Lucas and Claus, but Lucas, Kumatora, and Claus is my dream roster for the MOTHER series.
 

Tek32

Smash Cadet
Joined
Jan 10, 2008
Messages
36
Because of people like me that think Earthbound/MOTHER is a very bad franchise. Flame all you want I just don't like the games and don't think they deserve much representation in the Smash Bros. Games. I think they got TOO much representation, Ness/Lucas are practically the same (barring very minute differences), so why want another piece of crap?

Just my opinion on Earthbound and Mother =\
 

PrettyGoodYear

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 1, 2007
Messages
1,792
Location
Panama, Panama, Central America...
...So, basically, you'd rather have Sakurai ignore most of EarthBound's most memorable moves when giving Ness a moveset?

B: PK Flash
Smash B: PK Brainshock
Up B: PK Teleport
Down B: PSI Shield
Final Smash: PK Rockin'

That'd be awesome. Unless you factor in the fact that it's not.
Where's my Hypnosis? ¬¬ Actually, I'd rather have Rockin as a Special move and Dragon Powder as a Final Smash...

And most memorable moves? Huh? They're all memorable. Especially PK Rockin/Love.
 

Masque

Keeper of the Keys
Joined
Aug 9, 2001
Messages
2,660
Location
Subcon
To be honest, I think most people would prefer just Lucas and Claus, but Lucas, Kumatora, and Claus is my dream roster for the MOTHER series.
I would take either of those (perhaps even just the former), but that's purely a personal preference. ;)

Because of people like me that think Earthbound/MOTHER is a very bad franchise. Flame all you want I just don't like the games and don't think they deserve much representation in the Smash Bros. Games. I think they got TOO much representation, Ness/Lucas are practically the same (barring very minute differences), so why want another piece of crap?

Just my opinion on Earthbound and Mother =\
I pretty much couldn't care less about the Star Fox franchise, and I think they got too much representation. Rebuttal?

Frankly, I don't think you've ever played the games. You would instantly know that Ness and Lucas are nothing alike. The characters aren't simply "pieces of crap," especially not the next in line for Smash, Claus.

A valid opinion is not valid in and of itself, but requires the knowledge and experience to support said opinion. You're looking at things from a Smash perspective, which is EXACTLY what this thread is complaining about! The Smash series, glorious though it may be, is NOT an accurate depiction of the MOTHER series as a whole.

So not only have you (probably) not played any of the MOTHER games, but you undoubtedly have not read the thread itself (or at least not well...). :dizzy:

Didn't they confirm Duster as an AT at Jump Festa?
Supposedly. We received numerous reports about it (none describing his attacks, though). Seems kind of odd...
 

Big-Cat

Challenge accepted.
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
16,176
Location
Lousiana
NNID
KumaOso
3DS FC
1590-4853-0104
Frankly, I don't think you've ever played the games. You would instantly know that Ness and Lucas are nothing alike. The characters aren't simply "pieces of crap," especially not the next in line for Smash, Claus.
Personality wise, yes, but don't they have almost all the same PSI?
 
Top Bottom