Okay guys, so I have an update on our Zelda Finder page that I've been working on. This is only a small portion of it so far, but also the most important part of it. I have come up with 2 different versions so far and wanted to know what you guys thought about it from the sample user I've put up. I also have a version 3 which may come up depending on the feedback I get from you guys.
If this is too confusing to have all the versions in one post, then I can double/triple post it into the different versions, if the mods allow me.
So! Which one do you guys like so far? Which one do you guys not like so far? Do they all look okay? Would you rather wait for version 3 before having a final say? Do you have any suggestions? Please let me know ^^
Version 1)
Pros:
- Collapse tags make the page less clustered and less image heavy by allowing you to select the 'Show' link to display the rest of the user's information.
- Skimming by the names are easier because of the collapse tags
Cons:
- Looks too 'big' when you view the collapse tag, feels like there are lots of extra space on either side of the page.
- Even with the image and text centered, the text does not line up and looks rather untidy.
[COLLAPSE=""]
Username(s): Mocha
Tag(s): Mocha, Latte
Region: Houston, Texas
Offline/Online/Both: Both
Favorite Zelda color?: Blue
Other played characters: Snake, Pikachu, Mario, Peach
Contact: [ Smashboards ][ AllisBrawl ][ Brawl Friend Code ][ Youtube ]
Biography: You may write in text or do something more creative, like this:
[/COLLAPSE]
Version 2)
Pros:
- A much cleaner layout than the first, with an actual table to separate the categories
- Unlike the first version, looks easier on the eyes because it's smaller
Cons:
- Lack of collapse tags mean that the page may load slower once it gets filled with more images. Alternatively I could add a collapse tag to this too and keep this layout, but it makes the page look like it has extra borders, since this is already in a 'table' format.
- A real pain to edit. I literally have to edit every line to get it the size/style I want - though this is only apparent on the 'Biography' section, where there may be more than one line of text when one is going to describe themselves.
Username(s): Mocha
Tag(s): Mocha, Latte
Region: Houston, Texas
Offline/Online/Both: Both
Favorite Zelda color?: Blue
Other played characters: Snake, Pikachu, Mario, Peach
Contact: [ Smashboards ][ AllisBrawl ][ Brawl Friend Code ][ Youtube ]
Biography: You may write in text or do something more creative, like this:
Version 3)
Not yet released but this would basically be done on any one of my Microsoft Office programs (Word/Excel/Powerpoint) where I would make the graph and have it organized exactly the way I want, with far more options for font/formatting/etc than I have on this post edit. After I'm done, I would then save this as an image and post it here. I would have to keep updating it on the program, resaving and posting it here whenever people ask me to add them.
If you guys are really liking the sound of this option above the other two, let me know and I'll start working on it.