Everyone has a different perspective on what Smash Bros. could, should, and must be.
Factors like relevancy, sales, seniority, global appeal, marketing, fan demand, moveset potential, and the ‘Nintendo Connection’ aren’t clear cut, especially for Smash Bros or what are ‘premier franchises’. The likelihood is that it will never be clear cut. They are all factors. They are in many ways, contradictory.
I don’t think anyone is ready for cuts. Even those who say they are, likely aren’t. It’s never simple. It heavily depends on what factors you take into account when building a roster, and for some, it’s just a collection of faces they happen to like and nothing more.
Nostalgia has shifted. The fact is, the kids who grew up with the GameCube, DS, and Wii are adults now. Those games aren’t as easy to express their passion for as the NES/SNES era, especially compared to the indie boom of the 2010’s.
And again, the Switch is coming towards a decade old. Let’s not forget how successful this system is and how many people have nostalgia for it.
The Switch era is undeniably huge for many franchises. Series like Metroid, Kirby, Pikmin, and Xenoblade have hit heights they could’ve only dreamed of after the Wii U. The Switch 2 could see the same effect for long dormant series like Donkey Kong or Star Fox.
Personally, I think a roster hinging on ‘legacy’ or ‘timelessness’ again, whilst cutting a huge part of the roster is a hard sell to me.
After the Switch era, I think Nintendo leaning more towards their own series (and the Switch as a whole), especially in the base game, is a good move. That gives more reason to revisit Ultimate and a newer Smash game. Keeping a new game different, new, whilst keeping a good portion of veterans is the best call without feeling too bloated.
Yeah, we might lose fan favourites or third party icons, but it’s less severe than just swapping fan demand for fan demand, or a big third party for… another big third party.
Smash is very much a ‘helping hand’ for many series, both first and third party. But it can’t do it forever.