View attachment 401276
So, Uh... Tell me straight up does my personal Smash 6 roster suck? This is my newest revision and I cut a lot of stuff from the last one that I really like (Geno, Link’s Awakening remake Link, Shadow, A bunch of veterans.)
I know there is no objectively perfect way to make a Smash roster but I really just want it to be the best it can possibly be.
(By the way this is what the Picross question was for.)
At first this does seem reasonable at a glance, but I have some critiques about this roster.
-Aside from my preference for cutting both, if you had to remove either Rosalina or Bowser Jr. then I think you made the right choice of keeping the latter as he's far more prominent these days than Rosa. I'm assuming you're keeping Daisy as a Echo Fighter which I'm fine with.
-Waluig as a Wario rep would make sense if he was actually in Wario Land or Wario Ware but that's not the case. Outside of that technicality, I'm okay with him as a Mario newcomer though I would personally pick Paper Mario over him.
-Cutting King K. Rool is a choice, but one I can see happening. I'm more inclined to cut Diddy over K. Rool but either way will cause some backlash.
-Frankly I don't see how Skull Kid can a playable character as I don't see much moveset potential. It would make more sense if either Impa or Tingle became newcomers over him.
-Unless you are making Lucina her own unique fighter, I can't agree with cutting Robin due to their importance to the Fire Emblem IP and their moveset. You have to cut either Ike or Byleth and I'm more inclined to cut the latter since Ike is the most popular FE lord.
-Like many others, I question why you chose a regular Waddle Dee over Bandana Dee when the latter is a more distinct character.
-I think you need to reduce the number of Pokemon reps by at least one. Out of you have listed in this roster, I personally would remove either Lucario (due to him not be able to stand out) or Charizard (mainly to avoid Gen 1 bias). I almost want to cut Jigglypuff as well but they're like a Schrodinger's cat; they can sneak back into the roster.
-Why did you choose Z as a playable character over Noah and Mio? I'm genuinely baffled by this pick. If you wanted a playable Xenoblade villain, why not of with Malos or Jin. If you wanted a Xenoblade 3 rep that was not Noah and/or Mio, then you could have gone with Matthew or Rex. I want to know your rationale.
-DJ Octavio is not a bad choice for a new Splatoon rep, but he works better as a boss. I'm also more inclined to the Octolings/Agent 8 or one of the Idol groups (currently favor Off the Hook) as newcomers.
-Ignoring my preference all third party veterans from the base roster, keeping Pac-Man and Sonic makes sense since they have the strongest cases for returning. I don't see Smile working as a replacement for Hero nor as a base roster pick becuase of Square Enix.
Aside from what I listed, I have no objections to your other newcomer picks.