I've been wondering, what would reasonably be the size of the next roster if the next Smash is a normal entry (no Everyone is Here Deluxe and no "reboot") that focused on reworking some old fighters, adding new (and old) modes, includes newcomers, and obviously cuts some characters. Basically like the jump from Melee to Brawl and Brawl to Sm4sh. Maybe 60-ish characters? Brawl had around 40 characters if you include the transformations separately and Sm4sh around 50 in the base roster, so maybe it would scale upwards.
Currently, I’m of the mindset that the roster will be 60-70 fighters before echoes are included (pretty much close to or even at base Ultimate’s size) because Ultimate brought back 56 non-echoes and added 13 more, and I assume that assets will be reused to some degree similar to how For and Ultimate reused assets from their predecessors. In the end, I think 50-55 veterans and 10-15 newcomers before echoes seems like a reasonable assumption.
If you were to pick 5 new Mario Kart tracks to add as stages, which ones would you pick?
Current existing stages:
- DS Figure 8 Circuit
- 3Ds Rainbow Road
- WiiU Mario Circuit
DS Waluigi Pinball: I feel like this is a quintessential Waluigi thing.
DS Tick Tock Clock: I think this is a cool DS stage, and I think you could make an interesting SSB stage out of this.
Wii Maple Treeway: I thought about Coconut Mall, but the Rainbow Galleria idea also captivated my interest.
7 Music Park: Another interesting concept to incorporate into SSB.
8 Bowser’s Castle: A Bowser’s Castle stage is something that fans want, and I could see Nintendo getting a two birds one stone outcome here by adding a Bowser’s Castle and a Mario Kart stage.
So, when it comes to characters, every Smash game as far as I've seen has some popular/highly speculated characters which are 'now or never' in regards to timing and being included, meaning that if they ever get in it is in that particular Smash otherwise their chances quickly sail away due to their game being part of the past, due to being in a series with a revolving cast etc.
For Smash 6, outside of the Pokemon and Fire Emblem speculations, which characters that are very often brought up do you think are in a 'it's now or never' situation in regards to getting in? Like if they don't get in in Smash 6 they will probably never will?
Outside of flavor of the month fighters, I feel like the Tom Nook probably fits this situation the best. Tom Nook feels like Toad, Eevee, or Meowth where the character has the legacy to feel like a logical choice in a Nintendo/gaming crossover, and it‘s really Sakurai’s decision if he finds Tom interesting enough to add. In the cases of For and Ultimate, we respectively gained the player character in the form of Villager and the most popular NPC with Isabelle. Now that these two are in, Tom would be the most prominent choice to add next from Animal Crossing, and his inclusion will really hinge on Sakurai’s interest.
If Tom gets passed up next game regardless of a different Animal Crossing fighter joins, Sakurai/developers just may not find Tom Nook as a high priority fighter.
There is also a 3rd Mall stage option
Rainbow Galleria
Honestly, the one Super Mario stage that I would love to have is a Mario Party stage. From Jamboree, Rainbow Galleria is my favorite board, but an older board like Peach’s Birthday Cake, Space Land, Horror Land, Waluigi Island, or Sweet Dream would also be cool to see. Also, a booksquirm stage could be fun to play on.